Supreme Court upholds death for Nirbhaya’s rapists

The convicts are left with one more legal option of challenging their sentence before they appeal to the President for mercy

The convicts are left with one more legal option of challenging their sentence before they appeal to the President for mercy


New Delhi: The Supreme Court of India on July 9 ruled that the men convicted of raping and torturing a medical student on a moving bus in Delhi in 2012 will hang.

The apex court confirmed its earlier decision and rejected the request of three of four convicts for their sentence to be reduced to a life term.

The court was asked to reconsider its own ruling in a review plea; the convicts are left with one more legal option of challenging their sentence before they appeal to the President for mercy.

“There is no new material to review our order,” said three judges led by Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra, on the review petition of Mukesh, 29, Pawan Gupta, 22 and Vinay Sharma, 23.

The fourth death row convict, Akshay Kumar Singh, 31, has not filed a review petition against the Supreme Court’s judgment in May last year.

“People of our country have got justice. We hope the process is completed soon and the rapists get death, and society is safer for women,” said the woman’s mother, Asha Devi, on the court ruling that brings the convicts one step closer to execution.

A lawyer for the convicts, A P Singh, told reporters that “injustice” had been done to the convicted murderers – using the Hindi word for “boys” to describe them – and the court had caved to public and political pressure.

The Supreme Court had last year upheld the decisions of the Delhi High Court and the trial court sentencing the four men to death for raping the young woman, who died 16 days after the savage assault on December 16, 2012.

In its judgment, the Supreme Court had said that the “brutal, barbaric and diabolic nature” of the crime could create a “tsunami of shock” to destroy a civilized society, reports ndtv.com

The convicts appealed to the court to review their sentence, saying it was “cold-blooded killing in the name of Justice.” The court agreed to hear their request in November last year.

In its May 2017 judgment, the court concluded that the convicts “found an object for enjoyment in her… for their gross, sadistic and beastly pleasures… for the devilish manner in which they played with her dignity and identity is inhumane.”

On July 9, Justice Bhushan, who spoke for the Bench in his judgment, said the convicts cannot reargue their entire case in the guise of a review petition. The ambit and scope of a review petition was well-defined, and could only be entertained if there was judicial fallibility, miscarriage of justice and error apparent in the earlier apex court judgment, in this case the May 2017 verdict.

The gang-rape of the 23-year-old student, who was returning home with a friend after watching “The Life of Pi,” an English movie, provoked rage and shock across India and led to big changes to laws on sexual crimes against women. She died on December 29, 2012, at Mount Elizabeth Hospital in Singapore, The Hindu newspaper reported.

Of the six accused, bus driver Ram Singh killed himself in his prison cell. The youngest accused, just days short of 18 when he committed the crime, was sent to a juvenile home, from where he was released after a three-year term.

The woman came to be known as “Nirbhaya” or fearless. Her parents have said that all the rapists should be hanged at the earliest, including the youngest.

Have Something to Say? Comment on Facebook

1 thought on “Supreme Court upholds death for Nirbhaya’s rapists

  1. The death sentence has never served as a deterrent. It should be reserved only for waging war against the State. I would agree with the defence lawyer that the court has succumbed to public and political pressure.

Leave a Response