New Delhi: The eleventh round of talks between the federal government and farmers protesting the agriculture laws ended January 22 in a stalemate, as the previous ten did.
The farmer leaders refused to accept the government’s latest proposal – to put the controversial laws on hold for a year-and-a-half.
Unlike earlier talks, no date was set for the next meeting, with Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar telling farmers “the ball is your court now.” Tomar also said he was “sad” because farmer leaders did not seem to have “farmers’ welfare at the heart of (their) talks.”
“Talks remained inconclusive as farmers’ welfare was not at the heart of talks from the unions’ side. I am sad about it… We asked them to reconsider our proposal as it is in the interest of farmers and the country,” Tomar was quoted by news agency ANI.
More ominously, he also suggested the government would be ready for another round of talks only if the farmers wanted to discuss suspension of the laws.
“We also told farmers to give their own proposal, other than repeal of the Acts, if they have got anything better than our offer,” he said.
“Today’s meeting was only 15-20 minutes… no discussion was held. Government said we have done maximum we can do… if you (the farmers) want to go forward, tell us by noon tomorrow and we will arrange a new meeting,” Hannan Mollah of the All India Kisan Sabha told NDTV.
Mollah played down suggestions the government’s latest proposal – seen by many as a reasonable compromise – could divide what has been a strong stand by the farmers so far.
“I don’t think so… 95 percent of farmers are still united… maybe five percent is not (but) we are together in this. Today we will discuss and see if we can come to an agreement,” he added.
The farmers continue to insist – as they have since their protests began 60 days ago – that all three laws be scrapped and that the government provide legal guarantees for MSP (minimum support price).
“We told the government we will not agree to anything other than repeal of the laws,” Darshan Pal, a farmer leader with the Samyukt Kisan Morcha, told news agency PTI after today’s meeting.
The government, which says it will offer only written guarantees for MSP, this week followed up on the Supreme Court order halting implementation of the laws and suggested the 18-month stay.
This was after the top court put the laws on hold for at least two months and criticized the government for its apparent inability to resolve the agitation. The court also set up a committee to resolve the dispute, but that has been dismissed by farmers who say it consists of those in favor of the laws.
Meanwhile, after the latest meeting irate farmer representatives said they had been made to wait for over three hours for talks to resume after the two sides broke for lunch.
One leader told PTI that the government had spent less than 30 minutes in face-to-face talks.
The farmers have also reiterated that they will hold their tractor rally through Delhi on January 26 – Republic Day – despite the government appealing against this particular protest; the government called it “embarrassment for the nation” and asked the Supreme Court to intervene.
The court said it was a matter of “law and order” and had to be decided by Delhi Police, which is controlled by the federal government via the Union Home Ministry. Delhi Police (and police in BJP-ruled Haryana) came under fire last year for their handling of the farmers’ protest.
Farmer leaders have clarified that the rally — in which 1,000 tractors will participate — will be peaceful and won’t interrupt the day’s big parade at Rajpath.
Source: ndtv.com