By Irudhaya Jothi

Kolkata, November 21, 2026: In recent weeks, Christians in West Bengal have found themselves under a sharp public spotlight. West Bengal Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) president Samik Bhattacharya alleged that Christian missionary schools were involved in forced conversions and “anti-India activities,” warning that such institutions would not be allowed to continue. He offered no names and no evidence.

Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari responded that he would verify facts and act if complaints proved true.

Christian leaders firmly rejected the charges as baseless and damaging, while reporting dozens of attacks, vandalism of churches, disruption of prayer meetings, and intimidation of families since May 2026.

With Christmas approaching, community bodies have publicly appealed for government protection so they can worship and celebrate without fear.

Many Christians now feel isolated—targeted by a conversion narrative, anxious about festive security, and unsure of visible support from civil society or the wider Hindu majority that once prided itself on Bengal’s tradition of communal harmony.

This moment of vulnerability cannot be separated from a larger and more uncomfortable question raised only days earlier by veteran Christian leader and journalist John Dayal in UCA News:

“The larger question of whether Christians have been as involved as they should be in the people’s struggle for free and fair elections is embarrassing to the community.

“It exposes its own understanding of how far it can afford to go in solidarity with civil society and ordinary citizens without exposing itself to the wrath of a vindictive and majoritarian government and polity.”

Dayal’s observation forces an honest examination. For years, sections of the institutional Church in India—including in Bengal—have preferred caution over confrontation.

Institutional survival, fear of being labelled “political,” and a focus on internal pastoral and charitable work have often taken priority over sustained public solidarity with broader struggles for democratic integrity, land rights, livelihood, and ecological justice.

When the community later faces targeted pressure, the relative silence of the past leaves it feeling alone. Isolation is not only imposed from outside; it is also the consequence of earlier indifference.

Pressing Issues of Our Time

The conversion allegations and attacks on Christians are real and must be firmly opposed. Yet they sit within a wider landscape of pressure on constitutional values and ordinary people’s lives:

• Threats to free and fair elections, large-scale deletions from voter lists, and shrinking civic space.
• Environmental degradation, displacement of Adivasi and rural communities, and unequal development.
• Persistent youth unemployment and precarious livelihoods.
• Growing majoritarianism that makes religious minorities feel conditional citizens.
• The quiet erosion of life-promoting schemes that were meant to guarantee work, food, shelter, and education.

A Church that speaks only when its own institutions or festivals are threatened risks appearing self-interested.

A Church that remains silent on the sufferings of the wider poor and marginalised loses moral authority when its own turn comes.

Prophetic Response, Not Isolation

Christians in West Bengal and across India need not remain trapped in a cycle of anxiety and isolation.

The Gospel calls for a prophetic stance—truthful, courageous, and rooted in solidarity. Concrete steps can help:

  1. Speak clearly and consistently on constitutional rights
    Publicly affirm Article 25 (freedom of religion) and demand evidence-based governance. Reject both forced conversion and the weaponisation of conversion allegations. Insist that any genuine complaint be investigated through due process, not public vilification.

  2. Build visible, long-term solidarity beyond the Christian community
    Join and support civil society efforts on electoral integrity, farmers’ and workers’ rights, environmental protection, and against majoritarian violence—regardless of the victims’ faith. Past indifference created distance; present partnership can rebuild trust.

  3. Strengthen internal preparedness without retreating into fear
    Churches should continue practical safety measures (informing local authorities of programmes, community alert systems, CCTV, legal cells). At the same time, they must refuse the narrative that reduces Christian presence to a security problem.

  4. Form laity and youth for prophetic citizenship
    Invest in social analysis, constitutional literacy, non-violent advocacy, and interfaith dialogue. A prophetic Church is not only clergy-led statements but an educated, courageous laity that acts as salt and light in society (Matthew 5:13–16).

  5. Practise and demand mutual accountability
    Where individual or institutional wrongdoing occurs, address it transparently. At the same time, demand that political leaders and state agencies uphold the rule of law equally for all.

  6. Celebrate Christmas as an act of hopeful resistance
    Celebrate openly, peacefully, and inclusively—inviting neighbours of all faiths. Let the festival itself become a public witness to the dignity and belonging of the Christian community in Bengal.

Isolation is real, but it is not inevitable. The Church’s earlier caution may have narrowed its circle of solidarity; a prophetic turn toward the wider struggles of ordinary citizens can widen it again.

When Christians stand with the vulnerable even when they themselves are not the primary targets, they create the moral and social capital that others may one day draw upon in return.

First they came…
(Martin Niemöller)
First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me.
The poem is not a counsel of despair. It is a summons. The time to speak, to stand, and to build bridges is now—before the circle of isolation grows any tighter.

Make Your Comment!