Kashmir’s controversial missionary dies

Father Jim Borst worked in India for 55 years


By Jose Kavi

New Delhi: Father Jacobus (Jim) Borst, a noted missionary, retreat preacher and educationist from the Netherlands who was asked to leave India for alleged conversion works, died on September 5, the national Teachers Day. He was 88.

The Dutch missionary had spent most of his 55 years in India as a teacher in the troubled Jammu and Kashmir, the country’s only Muslim-majority state.

Father Borst “was suffering from heart ailments for some time now. He died at 11:45 am today,” Father Suresh Britto, who was with the elderly missionary at the time of his death, told Matters India over phone on September 5.

The Dutch missionary had gone to New Delhi in the last week of August to get a pacemaker and returned to Srinagar a couple of days ago.

The funeral has been scheduled for 2 pm on September 7 in Srinagar, Father Britto added.

Church people in the state say the Dutch missionary had done “yeoman service to the Kashmir Valley,” the heart of the state’s predominantly Muslim area.

Father Shaiju Chacko, spokesperson of Jammu-Srinagar diocese, told Matters India that “Father Borst was the last surviving Mill Hill Missionary in Jammu and Kashmir state.”

Father Borst had endeared himself to the people of the northernmost Indian state with his affectionate behavior, locals say.

Mohammed Shamim, a Muslim who had known Father Borst for years, described the missionary as “an affable priest” who was “always ready to talk to us and listen to us.”

Shamim other Muslims rallied behind Father Borst in April 2004 when Jammu and Kashmir´s Criminal Investigation Department told the missionary to leave India within 10 days.

The priest’s trouble began in 2003 when a national daily named him among those it said were leading the conversion of Muslims to Christianity.

Father Borst was then the principal of the Good Shepherd School in Kashmir Valley. Some Muslim groups had accused him of using the school as a cover for converting people.

While the missionary remained unfazed, the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of India branded the government move “myopic.”

Officials of the Jammu-Srinagar diocese that covers the entire state had rejected the allegations as unfounded and pointed out that only 15,000 of the state’s 10 million people were Christians.

Father Borst was born on August 3, 1930, in the Netherlands and joined Saint Joseph’s Missionary Society of Mill Hill, commonly called Mill Hill Missionaries, in 1945, soon after World War II ended. He was ordained a priest on May 7, 1957, in London, where his society was founded in 1886.

He came to Jammu and Kashmir in 1963 where his congregation had pioneered education and healthcare in the early 19th century.

Borst was also the principal of St. Joseph’s School, Baramulla, for two years from1974 and served as a parish priest of St. Joseph’s Catholic Church in the same town.

He directed Burn Hall School Srinagar for some time. He also translated the Bible into the local Kashmiri language.

In 1975, he went Bihar state, eastern India, where he worked until his return to Jammu and Kashmir in 1993. He is considered one of the pioneers of Catholic Charismatic Renewal Movement in India, Father Chacko said.

Have Something to Say? Comment on Facebook

5 thoughts on “Kashmir’s controversial missionary dies

  1. An amazingly holy and anointed priest, extremely humble. I had the privilege knowing him and listening to his talks for one week when Monica & I were in the school of Evangelisation in Pune. He used to come to the Bread of Life prayer group in Bangalore in the early years of the Renewal to share such anointed messages. Highly knowledgeable and spirit-filled. He has done amazing work in J&K and also Varanasi and was dearly loved by the locals despite many missionaries being sent out from there. Great loss to the Church in India. May His Soul rest in peace in the Lord. May the Lord continue to raise such instruments for the church in India. 🙏🏻🙏🏻

  2. He was a holy and humble man who truly believed that God wanted him to convert the Muslims in Kashmir. It is possible that a couple were converted. His best known convert was Joseph Predhuman Dar, a Kashmiri Brahmin who was highly educated and an officer in the Govt.

    It is also true that the others in the diocese were uncomfortable with his attempts to convert the Muslims, because it was leading to bad blood, and a threat to the big Catholic institutions. Later there were also allegations that he had founded his own congregation of sisters without the bishop’s permission.

    Be that as it may, he was indeed a good man who brought me closer to Jesus. May he now enjoy eternal bliss.

  3. I first met Fr Jim Borst when he visited our ashram in Bareilly in December 1975 and introduced us to the Charismatic Renewal. He was a deeply spiritual person. It is insultyto refer to him as a controversial person

Leave a Response

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.