By chhotebhai
Kanpur, October 26, 2026: The Indian Catholic Forum (ICF) previously gave a synopsis of the papers presented by learned speakers at the recently held “Synodal Church and Secular Society” discernment meet at Kochi, Kerala.
Based on the presentations and the deliberations that ensued, the participants proposed a Vision Statement. The following was the consensus view.
SYNODALITY: This was the thrust of the meeting, and its greatest concern. Though five years have elapsed, meetings have been held, and pious resolutions passed, nothing has changed on the ground. To the contrary there seems to be a backsliding, bolstered by a deeply entrenched clericalism.
It considers the laity as either fund raisers or crowd pullers. There is no genuine attempt at a participatory church, which is the core of synodality – walking together as fellow pilgrims.
Synodality must begin at the primary level of the parish. Besides an attitudinal change there is also need of putting in place systems that ensure genuine participation. The ICF calls for the following concrete measures to be taken:
- Empowerment and proper functioning of Parish Councils in both letter and spirit as envisaged in the Latin Code No536, read with 511-514, and its equivalent in the Oriental Code.
Meetings should be held on a regular basis with the Agenda circulated in advance and the Minutes duly recorded. - In the same spirit Finance Committees (Can 537) should also be activated and empowered.
- The establishment of Grievance Redressal Cells, at least at the diocesan level, should be set up, to avoid unnecessary litigation or scandals erupting in the public domain. This has been a long standing demand of the laity.
- Opaqueness leads to suspicion, gossip and distrust. Transparency is the need of the hour. If there is nothing to hide then there should be nothing to fear.
There should also be a Right to Information (RTI). Tragically almost all correspondence addressed to the hierarchy and even the Papal Nunciature is met by a stoic wall of silence. What then of dialogue, communication and community building? - Concern was also expressed at Catholic Associations in various dioceses being suspended or derecognized. If there are genuine problems they should be sorted out across the table.
Derecognition is not the solution. It only leads to more dissatisfaction.
LAY LEADERSHIP: We should give this utmost importance. Unfortunately, many laity believes that the only leadership role is by being elected/ nominated to ecclesiastical bodies/ institutions.
On the other hand true lay leadership should be in the secular field as envisaged by the Dogmatic Constitution of the Church (cf LG 31).
Hence we appeal to our people to assume leadership roles in business, industry, politics, legal, consumer, human rights and civic affairs; thereby becoming a counter veiling force in both Church and Society.
YOUTH: It was noted with dismay that though the youth are our own progeny they become enslaved to organizations controlled by the clergy.
This is distressing, more so since they are not being equipped to face the challenges of life or the faith. Hence the ICF should target those in the 30-40 age groups to bring up the next line of leadership.
MARRIAGE LAWS: Concern was also expressed about certain provisions in Canon Law pertaining to marriage. While referring to the responsibilities of marriage Canon Law states that ignorance of the same “cannot be presumed after puberty” (Can 1096:1 read with 1095)!
Bearing in mind that today’s generation often attain puberty by 10/11 years, and even much older persons cannot be presumed to understand the meaning of consent and obligations in a marriage bond, this canonical provision should either be repealed in its entirety, or suitably amended.
Another area of concern is that couples entering into a Mixed Marriage (Sister Church) or Disparity of Cult (Non-Christian) must obtain prior permission from the diocesan bishop (cf Can 1124 read with 1125. 1086 and 1129) and its equivalent in the Oriental Code.
When the government places such preconditions for religious conversions we cry foul, calling it an infringement of one’s privacy and the right to choose. Then why such double standards? This canonical provision should be scrapped or duly amended.
A declaration of intent and fidelity to Church teachings should suffice. What happens if the party is not on good terms with the parish priest or bishop? Will such an application be rejected and the parties left to fend for themselves?
ECUMENISM: We were happy to have three speakers, as also some participants, from sister churches. We should junk the British era coinage of “denominations” that is more appropriate for currency notes!
We should use the term “Sister Churches”, as scripture uses the term in plural (cf Rev 3:22). Our country does not distinguish between Catholics and other Churches. Hence we must work together in secular affairs. We cannot restrict our ecumenical efforts to the Christian Unity Octave (18th to 25th January).
In an ecumenical spirit we should also admit students from other churches to our educational institutions, more so where we have hardly 1% Christian students, yet claim Minority status and indemnity.
ANTI-CONVERSION LAWS: They are now a reality. Fighting expensive and tedious court battles is not the solution. We should not give an opportunity to our detractors by aggressive forms of evangelization or by condemning other religious practices.
We must respect all religions. We should counter false propaganda with facts; that our population has remained static at 2.3% since the 1971 Census. We can also draw attention to Vatican II teachings that prohibit forced or induced conversions (cf AD 13, DH 11).
FCRA: Certain provisions in the new law are draconian and patently unjust; especially the discretionary powers vested in the proposed “Designated Authority”, and the power to take over immoveable properties on the flimsiest of grounds. As in a SWOT analysis, we should see an Opportunity in every Threat.
Though we are 2.3% of the population we are reportedly the recipients of 21% of funds through FCRA. This is grossly disproportionate to our numbers.
This over dependence on foreign funds sometimes results in a disdain for local collaboration, even though the Dogmatic Constitution advocates inter-dependence based on mutual needs (cf LG 32).
Hence we should see this as an opportunity to evolve local sources of funding and mutual respect.
ORDINATION OF MARRIED PERSONS: Priestly celibacy is a manmade rule. Jesus healed the mother-in-law of Peter, the first Pope. 11 0f the 12 apostles were reportedly married.
Married clergy are already accepted in some of the Eastern Rite churches. The Latin Rite should jettison its stubborn refusal to ordain married persons. Marriage has an enriching effect and married clergy will definitely enrich and enliven the Church.
ORDINATIOM OF WOMEN: This is the most contentious issue. Over emphasis on the physical properties (masculinity) of Jesus is odious, Jesus, in human form was not just a male. He was a circumcised Jew, an Asian, who worked for several years as a carpenter.
He had nowhere to lay his head (cf Mat 8:20). He had long hair and a shaggy beard. How many priests today “resemble” him? Mere physical resemblance is a specious argument.
Who is a priest and what is his role? Would women fit into it? Ironically the Vatican II “Decree on the Ministry and Life of Priests” (Presbyterorum Ordinis) begins by saying that “The ministerial role has been handed down to priests in a limited degree” (PO 2 read with LG 28). So why should even this limited role be denied to women?
What are the duties of a priest? They are of Proclamation (PO 4), to make Christ present in a certain way in every gathering of the faithful (PO 5) and the “formation of a genuine Christian community” (PO 6). Are not women competent to fulfill these priestly functions?
Mother Mary fulfills these multiple functions like no other, which is why she is called the Queen of the Apostles. This is not just an honorific. She was indeed the greatest apostle. She unhesitatingly received the Word of God (Lk 1:37-38). She proclaimed the Incarnate Word (Lk 1:40-41).
She was a living sacrifice with a sword piercing her soul (Lk 2:35). This was addressed exclusively to her and not Joseph. She was a true contemplative “who treasured all these things and pondered them in her heart” (Lk 2:19).
She celebrated the Eucharistic sacrifice like no other, dying with Jesus on the Cross (cf Jn 19:25) while all those “strong, brave male disciples” abandoned him. She was the first to experience his Resurrection, hence had no need to run to the grave like those of lesser faith.
She was in the Upper Room (cf Acts 1:14) when Jesus breathed the Holy Spirit and gave the power to forgive sins (Jn 20:19-23). If Mary is not a priest then none of us are. We are mere pretenders to the throne.
In the light of the above we appeal to Church theologians to courageously address the issue of ordaining women to the ministerial priesthood.
CONCLUSION: The ICF is but a drop in the ocean. But Jesus asked us to be the leaven in the dough (I Cor 5:6) and salt of the earth (Mat 5:13).
They are negligible quantities but have a far reaching impact. It is hoped and prayed that our deliberations and discernment in the “Upper Room” of the Renewal Centre at Kochi will echo far and wide among all people of goodwill. It is part of the sensus fidei.
(The writer is the Convenor of the Indian Catholic Forum)











PARISH FINANCE COMMITTEES (PFCs)
Article 3: Competence
The Parish Priest is OBLIGED to hear his PFC or get its consent in accordance with these Statutes.
NUMBER OF MEMBERS
a) Depending upon the financial activity of the parish (not according to the number of parishioners), the minimum number shall be four (including PPC Secretary) and the maximum six. The parish priest is NOT INCLUDED in the membership.
2. The parish priest is OBLIGED TO HEAR the Finance Committee in the following:
a) To prepare the budget to expected income and expenditure for the following Financial Year for the entire administration of the parish.
b) For ANY NON-RECURRING EXPENDITURE on any single item estimated above INR 15,000/- (fifteen thousand) and below INR 25,000/- (twenty-five thousand).
c) To prepare the annual financial report which should be submitted to the Parish Pastoral Council, THE PARISHIONERS and to the Archdiocesan Finance Administrator.
(FOR THE FIRST TIME, ARCHBISHOP ELIAS FRANK HAS INCLUDED PARISHIONERS AS STAKEHOLDERS).
The parish priest is OBLIGED TO GET THE CONSENT of the Finance Committee in the following:
a) For any non-recurring expenditure (capital expenses) above INR 25,000/- (Twenty-five Thousand) and up to INR 50,000/- (Fifty Thousand) on a single item, such as the acquisition of new assets (e.g., gadgets…) or repairs.
b) For any non-recurring expenditure above INR 50,000/- (Fifty Thousand) apart from the consent of the PFC, also the approval of Archdiocesan Financial Administrator (DFA) is required. The Parish Priest SHALL SUBMIT A PETITION to the DFA, together with the necessary details, plans, and cost estimates, to obtain his permission.
c) To alienate (sale, exchange, lease, rent or gift) any immovable property of the parish (building or land) PRIOR TO GETTING the PERMISSION OF THE DFA;
d) Prior to getting the permission of the DFA regarding accepting any bequest or donation to which is attached any onerous obligation;
e) To put for sale gold, silver, statues or any other valuable objects that belong to the parish;
f) Prior to giving permission to put up public utilities like, playgrounds, halls, shops, melas etc., in the property that belongs to the parish.
g) Any action taken in violation of the provisions laid down in Art. 5, n. 3 is invalid, and the Parish Priest responsible for such action IS LIABLE TO COMPENSATE THE PARISH FOR ANY RESULTING DAMAGES (Can. 1376).
Article 7: MEETINGS
5. All resolutions shall be taken by majority vote of those present. When voting is taken, the Parish Priest will not vote.
6. In case of a tie, the Parish Priest must seek to bring about consensus. If no consensus is obtained, the matter may be dropped or may be referred, with the opinions of both sides, to the DFA.
7. For matters only of hearing (Article 5, n. 2) unless there is an overriding reason, he is not to act against its vote, especially if it is unanimous (can. 127 §2, 2º).
8. For matters of getting the consent of the Finance Committee the PARISH PRIEST IS BOUND BY THE VOTE OF THE MEMBERS. WHEN THE MAJORITY IS NOT IN FAVOUR OF HIS PROPOSAL, HE CANNOT ACT FURTHER.
From the above provisions, it is crystal-clear that the PARISH PRIEST CANNOT BYPASS THE PFC to seek clearance by the Diocesan Finance Administrator (DFA), the higher authority.
Overall, Archbishop Elias has made a near watertight PFC statutes. He deserves compliments for this.
Regarding Chhotebhai’s observations on PARISH PASTORAL COUNCILS (PPCs) and PARISH FINANCE COMMITTEES (PFCs), further elaboration is made below for ICF members and readers:
PARISH PASTORAL COUNCILS (PPCs)
The biggest bane of PPC is that it is a ‘Consultative’ body. This means despite the best and consensus advice given by the members, the parish priest can brush aside or override them. “It is the parish priest’s prerogative to take final decisions after due consultation” (Article 9 – Clause 5).
US-based McKinsey & Co., one of the topmost management consultancy firm in the world and at one time headed by Mr Rajat Gupta of Kolkata, would refuse to take up a consultancy assignment if the client did not give a written undertaking in the pre-proposal stage that it would implement all of McKinsey’s recommendations. Post-1991, it would charge a minimum fee of INR One Crore for an assignment in India. On McKinsey’s part it used to give an undertaking that it won’t do a similar assignment for another client/state government for two years.
However, in the case of Calcutta Archdiocese Archbishop Elias Frank has inserted a countervailing (balancing) clause 2 in PPC statutes as follows:
Article 3: COMPETENCE
1. The PPC possesses a consultative vote. It means that the deliberations arrived at the meeting must necessarily be approved by the parish priest (can. 536 §2).
2. The parish priest will not decide against the Council’s counsel, especially if unanimous, without a reason that is overriding in his judgement (can. 127 §2, 2º)
Among various clauses on the purpose of the Parish Pastoral Council under Article 4: SCOPE, there is an interesting clause:
g. To confront any major issue that affects the pastoral life of the parish
So, it is for readers to conclude whether the articles are conflicting (Article 3 vis-à-vis Article 9 (5) mentioned above.
Finally, it is the Archbishop alone who gives authentic interpretation to these Statues (Article 11 – Various, point 4).
With reference to Chhotebhai’s observations on Empowerment and Proper Functioning of Parish Pastoral Councils (PPCs) and Parish Finance Committees (PFCs), the biggest bane of PPC is that it is a CONSULTATIVE Body. This allows the Parish Priest to brush aside or override the recommendations, even if unanimous, of PPC members. However, in the PPC statutes of the Archdiocese of Calcutta, Archbishop Elias Frank in his wisdom, has put in the following two clauses as a countervailing measure (balancing act):
The PPC possesses a consultative vote. It means that the deliberations arrived at the meeting must necessarily be approved by the parish priest (can. 536 §2).
The parish priest will not decide against the Council’s counsel, especially if unanimous, without a reason that is overriding in his judgement (can. 127 §2, 2º).
In Article 4: Scope, the Archbishop has inserted two clauses, the latter being quite intriguing:
f. To plan jointly with the Parish Finance Committee for the construction and maintenance of buildings and parish property;
g. To confront any major issue that affects the pastoral life of the parish;
In Article 11: Various
4. It is the Archbishop alone who gives authentic interpretation to these Statues. I guess point 4(g) above will come under this.
Article 12: Amendments
Amendments to these Statutes may be proposed to the Archbishop, who alone has the authority to
amend them and, if he considers it necessary or useful, may do so.
The Parish Priest has been given the licence to call the minimum number of meetings, that is one meeting every three months / every quarter, if he wants to avoid his probing PPC members!
Enunciation on the following area mentioned by Chhotebhai in his report on ICF Convention in Kochi:
RIGHT TO INFORMATION (RTI): When the hierarchy does not bother to even acknowledge correspondence, demand for RTI is tantamount to will-o’-the-wisp.
CONCERN AT CATHOLIC ASSOCIATIONS IN VARIOUS DIOCESES BEING SUSPENDED OR DERECOGNIZED. – Church cannot be entirely faulted for this. The 115-year-old Catholic Association of Bengal (CAB) is a clear case in point. As per CAB’s Constitution (also known as ‘Blue Book’), the office bearers were elected, in the presence of then Ex-Officio Chairman Archbishop Thomas D’Souza, for a term of three years in September 2018. Their elected term lapsed in September 2021. Yet the so-called “first woman president of CAB” is holding on to power by misuse of her TMC affiliation, ostensible connection with those who wield political power (now completely routed by BJP), her money power and threat of police action against upright members who speak up. In her ‘uncatholic’ manipulations/greed for power, she is being backed by persons with their own vested interests, including a 70+ senior school principal and the God-fearing Hony Treasurer who has been dangled the carrot of being nominated by her as the next Anglo-Indian MP – though this position has been scrapped for good by the NDA government! So, all the hangers-on in the CAB Executive Committee have an axe to grind by using CAB platform! They are not in CAB to serve the Catholic community of Bengal. Archbishop Emeritus Thomas D’Souza who publicly swore by ‘Didi’, chose to sit quiet on the matter. He was notorious for sweeping matters under the carpet. The current Archbishop is also tightlipped on the matter. He can easily show the door (CAB’s registered office is in the Archdiocese of Calcutta Middleton Row premises) to the culprits who unabashedly swear by St Teresa of Calcutta (CAB’s Patron Saint) and are doing everything uncatholic. Instead of cleaning his own stable, the Archbishop is busier with Bangiya Christiya Parisheba (BCP) whose leaders are trying to hog the limelight by harping on growing Christian persecution in Bengal. BCP leaders sold him the idea that only they can take up cudgels for all Christians of Bengal! Ironically, BCP’s own CNI parent-church is cold-shouldering them!! It is evident even under the new Archbishop, the Archdiocese of Calcutta continues to have lopsided priorities!
LAY LEADERSHIP IN BUSINESS, INDUSTRY, POLITICS, LEGAL, CONSUMER, HUMAN RIGHTS AND CIVIC AFFAIRS: Chhotebhai is dead right. Lay leadership in secular fields will bring true emancipation of the church which oddly fears lay leaders with strong spinal cords. It simply detests the word ‘secular’ and equates it with being anti-Christ. My question to the Hierarchy is how Christ-like is it in terms of simplicity and compassion, the first and foremost qualities of a priest?
MANDATORY PERMISSION FROM THE DIOCESAN BISHOP BY COUPLES ENTERING INTO A MIXED MARRIAGE (SISTER CHURCH) OR DISPARITY OF CULT (NON-CHRISTIAN). WHAT HAPPENS IF THE PARTY IS NOT ON GOOD TERMS WITH THE PARISH PRIEST OR BISHOP? WILL SUCH AN APPLICATION BE REJECTED AND THE PARTIES LEFT TO FEND FOR THEMSELVES? The simple answer is they will just leave the church and may be start a “Home Church!” Their exit is the church’s loss (pastoral and other support), not theirs! We are witnessing such a trend (dwindling pews) in Western countries including Germany where Christians pay 10% of their income as Tithe (church tax).
WE SHOULD USE THE TERM “SISTER CHURCHES”: Forget “Sister Churches”, even our own Catholic churches discriminate among themselves – Jesuits, Diocesans, Salesians and other congregations. Case in point: On 10th October 2026, Deacon Prosenjit Paul Gomes was ordained as a Jesuit in Prabhu Jisur Church, Kolkata. His express wish was to be ordained in his home parish (St Teresa’s Church Kolkata). But St Teresa’s parish priest put a spoke in his wheel by deciding that since he wanted to be a Jesuit priest, he should be ordained in a Jesuit Parish! When we were discussing this backstabbing over lunch at Prabhu Jisur Girja, one very senior priest there remarked “How idiotic of St Teresa’s PP! Besides loss of face, the material loss (ordination mass collection) would be of St Teresa’s Parish’s!” These are the thick-headed shepherds we are coming across nowadays. They lack both vision and compassion, the principal attributes of a priest. They consider themselves as owners of their parish (fiefdom) and not ‘stewards.’ In this connection, readers and ICF members may refer to the link http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/16761845.cms?utm_source=contentofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst on a Kerala High Court judgement dated 10 October 2012 which ruled that parishioners have rights over church property.
FCRA: It’s admitted that certain provisions in the proposed amended law are draconian, especially the discretionary powers vested in “Designated Authority”, to take over immovable properties on arbitrary grounds. However, the Church’s over-dependence on foreign funds needs to be phased out by tapping local sources of funding. For this the projects need to be transparent to elicit donations from philanthropic organisations/business houses, several of them being Christians. Also, the amended rules must be read thoroughly to avoid cancellation of FCRA registration on technical grounds. This responsibility falls squarely on our Church institutions’ internal auditors too.
Chhotebhai, as Convenor of Indian Catholic Forum (ICF), has raised several pertinent points regarding the Indian Catholic Church. Given below are my candid take on some areas mentioned in the report:
SYNODALITY: Though Pope Francis initiated Synodality, it hardly made any headway. Because in its heart of heart, the entire Church Hierarchy, did not and does not believe in Synodality (to ‘unquestioningly’ listen to the aam aadmi beginning with the grassroots and seek their participation in the Church). The Hierarchy feels by Synodality, it will lose its grip on the ‘lambs/sheep’ (the disdainful euphemism for Laity) who it always wants to be meek and mute. In fact, it has hardly any concern for the Laity except making them milking cows (‘Pay, Pray and Obey’) and use them for candlelight processions in case of perceived persecution (FCRA!
Participatory church is out of the question, for the equal participants will raise questions and expect answers. As Chhotebhai has pointed out, most bishops/archbishops do not even acknowledge emails/letters. Getting answers from them, except through legal notices, is a rarity. This is the experience I have of the immediate past and the current Archbishop of the Archdiocese of Calcutta. Chhotebhai has already mentioned about the stonewalling expertise of the Nuncio. They all follow the same pattern – stonewall all communications by remaining “Incommunicado.”
PARISH PASTORAL COUNCIL (PPC) and PARISH FINANCE COMMITTEE (PFC): Experience tells me that most parish priests drag their feet on the formation of PPC and particularly PFC. The new Archbishop Elias Frank of Calcutta issued Statutes (much more precise than his predecessor) on the mandatory formation of PPCs and PFCs in each parish. The statutes came into effect from 1st January 2026 but several parishes haven’t formed their PFCs. Auxilium Parish (Salesian) Kolkata is one such instance. It has never had a PFC. The parish just don’t care for any financial accountability. To it, the Salesian Provincial is its Archbishop! How many parishes maintain Assets Register for inspection by parishioners? Whoever raises financial questions, is branded ‘Anti-Church’ and even ‘Anti-Christ’!
Regarding holding PPC & PFC meetings on a regular basis with the agenda circulated in advance and the Minutes duly recorded, the newly formed PPC of St Teresa’s Church Kolkata, agreed on at least once-a-month meetings. The Parish Priest only adheres to the minimum norm of Quarterly Meetings, that is four times a year. About PFC statutes, recently he suddenly started construction of a new washroom in the parish. He said this was exclusively for the Archbishop’s use whenever he visits the parish! The question raised by parishioners is who uses the custom-made washroom when the Archbishop isn’t on his pastoral visits? Though it is a Capital Expenditure, no formal proposal was put up to the PFC by this parish priest (who is a qualified lawyer!). The PFC statues clearly state that for any non-recurring expenditure above Rs 15,000 PFC’s sanction must be taken and for any such expenditure above Rs 50,000/- first the PFC’s and then Archdiocesan Financial Administrator’s (DFA) express approval must be taken by parish priest. The statutes also mandate (1) ‘Prior to giving permission to put up public utilities like, playgrounds, halls, shops, melas etc., in the property that belongs to the parish. (2) Any action taken in violation of the provisions laid down is invalid, and the Parish Priest responsible for such action is liable to compensate the parish for any resulting damages (can. 1376).
GRIEVANCE REDRESSAL CELLS: How many parishes in India have this? No parish in the Archdiocese of Calcutta has this. Not even a Diocesan Grievance Cell. If it existed, it would be mentioned in the Archdiocesan website. As of today (30.10.2026) no such cell exists in the Archdiocese under the head ‘Diocesan Officials’ or Commissions/Apostolates.
TRANSPARENCY: The Indian Church (both Catholic, CNI and other sister churches) simply do not believe in transparency. It’s a big “No No.” Their intent simply is not to divulge much unless compelled.